
I must acknowledge an appreciation for the sixth season as a whole before delving into the finale. There were far fewer low points than usual for a 26 episode season. The highs were higher on average than normal, too boot. While Tng is a classic anyway, I daresay it should have ended after six. Certainly, I would have liked for it to go out on a better story than “Descent” managed to be, but in hindsight, I would prefer that than most of the incredibly odd seventh and final season. But one takes what one gets, for better or for worse.
Back in the pre-internet Dark Ages, a fan had to rely on magazines for spoilers. Those were often from the production company’s public relations department, so you never got good stuff. These days, you know everything about the season finale before you open your Christmas presents thanks to the world wide web. Even the Atlantic Ocean is no enough of a barrier to keep
Doctor Who stuff a secret. So a couple weeks prior to seeing “Descent, Part I,” I stumbled across a tabloid article touting the appearance of Stephen Hawking, the most special effects laden sequence in the show’s history, and the return of the Borg. Knowing all this stuff beforehand was a totally cool experience back then.
As if you needed any further proof why the science minded fans hates the humanities oriented ones, I do not care about Hawking. I appreciate the novelty of him being on the show. He is a fan and, to date, is the only person to ever play himself on any Trek. I appreciate his theories about the beginning of the universe, but am perpetually irritated how God fits well within them, yet he refuses to acknowledge God as the Uncaused Cause. For what it is worth, I think more highly of Hawking than the purple faced angry fundamentalists types from Bob Jones university and Regent University I have encountered over the years.
I will also grant how they included him as neat. Data decides to gather the greatest physics minds in history--Hawking, Albert Einstein, and Isaac Newton-- on the holodeck for a poker game to see how they interact socially. The great John Neville plays Newton. The sequence is full of subtle jokes, so as Hawking noting Einstein is wrong several times--a nod to how Hawkings has proven a number of Einstein’s theories incorrect. They also throw in the false belief that Einstein could not do simple math. Folks, that isan urban legend. Einstein was a mathematical genius and always was.
Next, the most special effects laden sequence of the series. Yes, it was indeed cool for a television series. The
Enterprise responds to a distress call out an outpost only to find it has been attacked by the Borg. They wind up in the biggest phaser battle perhaps in all of trek. These Borg are different. They are individuals rather than part of the Collective and highly vicious.
In the midst of the battle, Data is attacked in hand-to-hand combat. He gets visibly angry and breaks the Borg’s neck. When the batte is over and the Borg have fled the scene, he is still standing there. The android has experienced his first emotion. It is unsettling.
The next scene is the weakest of the episode. It is the obligatory conference room meeting where all the necessary exposition is laid out. The dialogue is so stiff and stereotypical, it would not pass muster in a
Scooby Doo cartoon. Riker notes these new Borg have individual names. Troi pipes up that only Hugh hasa nameandthey gave it to him. Well thanks for adding that. Picard says that if the Borg are no longer interested in assimilating technology, since they left all equipment alone on the outpost, then they have to find out what the their new intentions are. Uh…you think? For a few minutes there, I though Maurice Hurley might be back to pen the episode.
Tha previous weak segment is almost made up for by the next. Admiral Nechayev finally confronts Picard about his dealings with the Borg. If you have been reading my reviews for awhile now, you will know I have been perplexed by how willing Starfleet wa sto allow Picard to go back to his role as flagship captain after his time as Locutus without any concern he might still be under their influence. My bewilderment was only exasperated when he discovered the Borgthe crew would eventually name Hugh, nurse it back to health, and send back to the Collective rather than hand him over to Starfleet intelligence for study. The admiral finally chews him out for wrestling with his conscience rather than making the concerns of the Federation in priority. I would almost call it too little, too late, but there you go. She still puts him in charge of dealing with the Borg, so obviously Starfleet command ignores its concerns on up until
Star Trek: First Contact.
On a side note, the admiral names a number of ships flying to the area to join in the Borg hunt. One of them is the
Gorkon. Gorkon was the name of the Klingon chancellor assassinated in
Star Trek VI: The undiscovered Country. But it is a Federation ship, not a Klingon vessel. Chalk it up the TNG’s weird liberalism to name a ship after an enemy leader who ended a cold war. Would the United states name a ship the
Gorbechev? I have doubts.
The Borg attack the
Enterprise and one is captured. It is all part of a ruse to get to Data. The Borg, Crosis, uses a device to create emotions in Data. This illuminates another couple points I think are weak. One, Data has admitted to Troi he not only felt anger, but pleasure at killing the Borg who attacked him. No one gets freaked out by this. Two, during the attack on the outpost, the Borg expressed concern over their fallen comrades. Yet one of them had to be sacrificed in data’s rage. It is contradictory. Of course, the anger over the fallen is just thrown in to emphasize these Borg are different, so the whole sequence is a sign of bad writing.
Data helps Crosis escape. They disappear through some trans warp hole in space thingy. The
Enterprise eventually follows and winds up 6,000 light years away or a distance it would take six years to travel, if you prefer. They come to a planet where Dataand Crosis have landed. You may recognize it as the same area the TOS episode “This Side of Paradise” was filmed. This is one of the extremely rare instances both TOS and TNG filmed in the same remote location.
Picard, la Forge, and Troi investigate what looks to be an abandoned building, but are soon surrounded by Borg. The mastermind of the operation is revealed to be Lore, with data, now eaten up with negative emotions fed to him. The two plan to destroy the Federation.
To be continued…
“Descent, Part I” has some serious weak points as I have noted. They distract, but do not necessarily ruin the episode. Still, I would label it the weakest cliffhanger of the season finales to date. I appreciate the classic ending. How many villains want to conquer the good guys completely? It is like the plotline of taking over the world. We are so cynical about the way things are, it is impossible to imagine some megalomaniac
wants to take over. But still, it is just mediocre. Bonus points, oddly enough, are awarded to Crusher for being the first woman left in command of the
Enterprise. It only took 27 years for it to happen. Yay, women’s liberation!
Rating: ** (out of 5)