Doctor Who--"The Chistmas Invasion" (Commentary)
The Sci Fi Channel begins airing the second season of the revived
Doctor Who tonight for the first time in the United States. The season ran from April to July of this year. I have viewed and recapped each episode during that time span and do not plan to technically do so again. After such a short time period, I am not eager to see most of the episodes again. Indeed, a couple of the later installment do not merit repeat viewing at all. However, I know from experience enough Americans will be watching the series for the first time that the internet will be aflutter with activity regarding the show. Okay, most will be looking for Bilie Piper naked, but I have all your Billie Piper needs taken care of in the sidebar. Photos galore, as they say. There appears to be something about her in “New Earth” that attracted a lot of searches the first time around, but I have yet to figure out what.. I thought she was much sexier in “The Impossible Planet/The Satan Pit,” but what do I know?
I am going to link to my original reviews and add in some original commentary. Not really a recap, but more like some additional thoughts on each episode. Thanks to making music videos for YouTube, I have had the opportunity to view these episodes more than once already and gained a bit more insight into most. Ranted, not all episodes have a lot of meat to them. Some of these writings are really short, but I have dabbled with them periodically over recent weeks to make sure these are not just thrown together at the last minute drivel just to catch a web searcher or two. I am by no means a true film or television critic, but I take these things apart as best I can. To whit:
First up we have David Tennant’s inaugrual turn as the Tenth Doctor. I find that a bit misleading. Truth be told--and this is a preview of much of the season--Rose Tyler (Billie Piper) takes center stae. I have had awfully limited experience with the original series, but I think it is safe to say Rose has been the most assertive companion the Doctor has ever had. She is the hero of at least two of the thirteen episodes plus this holiday special. Old time fans have been frustrated about that, but I thought it added a certain angle that was lacking in the old series. Then the Doctor was a now all, do all type who most often had to save his companions (male and female alike) while making kiddie table flirtations with the girls. It was not until Rose came along that any serious attempt was made to make companions an asset or romantic interest.
(Yes, I will grant you the 1996 movie had some romantic elements, but I am thinking a lot of fans debate the canonicity of a number of elements--most prominently whether the Doctor cares about sex. One assumes he does or else that explains why he spends his life battling Daleks and Cybermen--frustration.)
There certainly was no kiddie table flitation between Rose and either the Ninth or Tenth Doctors. I have made no secret I prefer the first season and Christopher Eccleston’s portaryal of the Doctor for various reasons, but one of the least was the cornier elements of his relationship with Rose. Actually, corny I only half of it. Their relationship was often stormy and uncomfortable. At times, the Doctor is incredibly abusive, particularly considering Rose is an inexperienced 19 year old in way over her head. I have chalked a lot of it up to British sensibilities, as there seems to be a certain caustic way about them which does not betray an actual animosity. I figured this out after having a British professor in college and befriending a girl from Lancashire in law school, both of him seemed rude and often emotionally cold, yet both wound up being loyal, comforting souls when it counted. It is all about the cultural differences. I suppose that is why Rose was so attached to the Ninth Doctor despite his abuse. Throughout “The Christmas Invasion,” Rose is torn as to whether she wants to travel with the “new’ Doctor because of her attachment to the old.
The dynamic of their relationship definitely changes as Rose decides she does want to stay in the TARDIS. Now that we now Billie Piper planned to leave at the end of the season, it is clear they were both helping push her character out the door and showing why romance between the Doctor and his companions is a bad thing. The character of Rose was meant to build the Nnth Doctor, melancholy, war broken, and near suicidal, back to the confident hero he is supposed to be. Those elements are prominent in the first season in which the Ninth Doctor shows Rose the Earth’s destruction in five billion years so she can relate to his feelings about losing Gallifrey and allowing to (unwisely) witness her father’s death in “Father’s Day” so she will understand what it is like to lose family as he has. Rose took all this and nearly sacrificed herself in “The Parting of the Ways” to restore the Ninth Doctor’s faith. She was successful. Too much so, really. There were not any places to go with she and the Tenth Doctor’s relationship after that other than romance. When we get to “School Reunion” and “The Girl in the Fireplace,” you will see why that fails as well.
One other element that is different here: while the Tenth Doctor seems more relaxed and happy go lucky, he is a no second chances kind of guy. The Ninth Doctor thought highly of UK prime Minister Harriet Jones at a time when he loathed most humans. Yet after she destroys the fleeing alien ship in tonight’s episode, he destroys her political career with just a few words. This puts in mind that no matter how much affection he may have for rose, he would have been harder on her than the often brutal Ninth Doctor for intervening in her father’s accident in “Father’s Day.” I do not believe h would have forgiven her or changing history.
Despite that character trait, the Tenth Doctor, at least in his first outing, seems to be a goofy adventurer who appears to not be aware of his surroundingss, yet is keenly on top of things. Later on he develops into much more of a man of action with a greater sense of fun than the Ninth Doctor ever had. He also seems less lecherous as far as th young girls go than the Ninth Doctor, yet often colder emotionally. There are interesting parallels and contrasts that pop up throughout the season, some of which seem oddly out of character, but we will get to all that later. Right now just bear in mind there is a certain emotional frivolousness to the Tenth Doctor, particularly in regards to Rose. He goes up and down annoyingly with her and is in a couple of cases blatantly dishonest with her. Admittedly, it is something of a turn off, yet fans who were into relationship speculation do not seem to agree. But that is a for further exploration down the line.
“The Christmas Invasion” is a decent first outing for the Tenth Doctor even if he is comatose for most of the episode after a rough regeneration. Our first view of Torchwood, the season’s theme, is prominent even though the actual secrecy of the organization goes up and down as the season progresses through different time periods. Sometimes it is totally covert, above the law and other times it seems like the organization is on the public’s call just like the police. I suppose it will take the premiere of the
Torchwood series in October to completely clarify all that. Perhaps Rose attaches herself to the new Doctor a bit too quickly as well, but there might be enough of the Ninth Doctor in him to justify it. It is hard to say. I much preferred the Ninth Doctor and as good as the Tenth is, he just cannot hold a candle to his predecessor.
You may read my original "The Christmas Invasion" review
here.